Franchises are Built on Hope

Before the Bye Week, the Titans gave fans a glimpse of what complementary football looks like. Even with the trade of Jeffery Simmons to the Chicago Bears, the Titans showed up against a high-performing Bengals team. Yes, they fell short, but this game could be a glimpse of what fans could see in the coming seasons from Cam and the Tennessee Titans.
The Titans turned up the heat against Cincinnati despite being without their №1 wide receiver, Carnell Tate. Tennessee fell 43–36 in overtime at Paycor Stadium, dropping to 1–7 heading into the bye week. The offense went up 13–0 early, and the defense couldn’t stop the Bengals from climbing back. A combination of dropped passes and the offense not being able to stay on the field once again led to a team implosion and a loss in overtime. Was this a complete loss for the Titans, or was there a spark that could grow in the coming weeks?
Cam Ward
Cam Ward wasn’t perfect, but his decision-making and pocket presence seemed to be better in this game. Ward completed 26 of 40 passes for 304 yards and two touchdowns with no interceptions, the first 300-yard game of his career. He made some solid moves with his legs, gaining 40-plus rushing yards, and even had a big run on a busted play on a 2-point conversion.
Cam Ward was drafted with the first pick of the NFL draft and doomed from that point on. If Cam were a second- or third-round pick, fans would be much more understanding of his progress, but Daboll is pressured to make Cam worth the first-round pick.
It matters because the Titans have only won one game this season. Ward has shown minimal flashes as the starting quarterback, and fans are anxious to see him prove he is the right quarterback for the job.
Tony Pollard
Tony Pollard ran for 117 yards and two touchdowns on 21 carries. At this point, I would keep Pollard in the backfield to be a leader alongside Cam Ward. Tyjae Spears doesn’t seem like he’s going to pan out for the Titans, and Nick Singleton could show more potential at the №2 RB spot. With the Simmons trade bringing in heavy draft capital, the Titans could make a play for any position, but I don’t see running back being the choice since Pollard looks to be rolling efficiently for the Titans.
Pass Catchers
This was Gunnar Helm’s first big game. He caught five of nine targets for a career-high 76 yards and caught a 2-point conversion. Helm is a franchise-level tight end and should be included more in the passing game to open up opportunities for the wide receiver corps.
Young wide receivers Chimere Dike and Elic Ayomanor are proving to be worth their draft picks. Dike caught five passes for 71 yards and a touchdown, and Ayomanor has 13 catches for 211 yards and a touchdown on the season. Dike brings special teams usage to the table, but from what I’ve seen, Ayomanor has been very consistent through the season.
The Wan’Dale Robinson pickup in the offseason isn’t working out for the amount of money he was paid. Robinson signed a four-year, $70 million deal in March. He caught six passes for 57 yards Sunday, including the go-ahead 15-yard touchdown with 3:46 left, but his second-quarter fumble ended a drive in Bengals territory. Robinson isn’t making big-time plays in the slot. He is absolutely an athlete, but for the price the Titans are paying, they need him to be a leading №2 receiver on the team. Only three TDs and 262 yards this season just isn’t acceptable.
Defense
The Titans traded Jeffery Simmons to the Bears on Thursday for Chicago’s 2027 and 2028 first-round picks. While it pains fans to see Simmons in a Chicago uniform, the timing works out for both teams in this scenario. The Bears are potentially contending for a Super Bowl appearance, and the Titans are in need of draft capital to continue building a foundation in Nashville.
Simmons wasn’t on the field, but Jacob Martin and Amani Hooker emerged as leaders of the defensive unit on the day.
Martin finished with three sacks, including a 15-yard sack on fourth-and-2 from the Tennessee 5 late in the second quarter that turned the Bengals away. Martin played fast and violent. Fans will look for him to continue that aggressive performance as the Titans look to fill the void left by Simmons.
Amani Hooker intercepted Burrow three times, tying a franchise record and becoming the first NFL player with three picks in a game since 2023. Unfortunately for Titans fans, Hooker was traded to the Buffalo Bills before the trade deadline paired with a 2027 5th-Round pick for a 2027 2nd Round pick. While the loss of Hooker is massive, the compensation was warranted to help the grwoth of this young team.
Joe Burrow still dominated the air raid with 462 passing yards. The secondary was shredded by both Tee Higgins and Ja’Marr Chase. Higgins caught 10 passes for 155 yards and two touchdowns, and Chase added 11 catches for 141 yards and a touchdown. Burrow was moving down the field at will once the Bengals quit turning the ball over.
How It Slipped Away
I would say that the loss to the Bengals is split equally among the play-calling, the defense and decisions made by Cam Ward late in the game.
Early in the third quarter, Ward was strip-sacked in Titans territory, and Higgins scored on the very next play to put Cincinnati up 21–13.
Daboll calling an HB draw when the Titans were backed up on the 3-yard line, resulting in a safety, made no sense at all with the placement of the ball. The safety gave the Bengals a 23–21 lead late in the third quarter. Yes, the HB draw was a bad call, but that’s also a bad position no matter what play you run.
Cincinnati missed a 2-point try after Mike Gesicki’s touchdown left the Bengals up 29–28, and Ward answered with the touchdown to Robinson and a 2-point pass to Helm for a 36–29 lead. The defense allowed the Bengals to march downfield in the fourth quarter and score to tie the game.
Ward was sacked by Dexter Lawrence for a 13-yard loss on third-and-3 from the Cincinnati 45 with 32 seconds left. The late sack took the Titans out of potential field goal range to try to take the lead with almost no time left on the clock. Ward has to throw the ball away there instead of taking a sack.
Joe Burrow was also able to move around in OT and run in a touchdown that would seal the win for the Bengals. On the Titans’ possession, a bad snap on second down wasted a play, and Ward’s fourth-and-3 pass to Ayomanor fell incomplete.
Final Thoughts:
There’s a lack of consistency in all phases of the game. The Titans are a product of their coaching, but Saleh is a defensive-focused head coach with a defense that is fragmented. Saleh can’t be expected to have a team that performs on both sides of the ball if the offense can’t stay on the field. There was a glimmer of some hope on the offensive side of the ball I look for the Titans to build on in the coming weeks.
Grades:
Offense: C
Defense: D
Special Teams: B-
Cam Ward: C
Up Next
Right tackle JC Latham left in the third quarter with a finger injury, and left guard Peter Skoronski was carted off in the fourth with a hamstring injury. At the start of the season, the offensive line was one of the most worrisome units on the Titans. These injuries on Sunday remove two of the best options for protecting Cam Ward. If Skoronski and Latham don’t return for the Jaguars, expect a rough outing for the Titans offense.
Tennessee hosts Jacksonville at Nissan Stadium on Nov. 15. Get Carnell Tate healthy, rest and keep Cam Ward warm. We need to see him come alive against a tough Jacksonville Jaguars team after the bye week. The Jaguars will obliterate the Titans on their offensive side of the ball as Trevor Lawrence dices up the secondary.